Skip to content
Brookguard

Filing a Car Insurance Claim, Step by Step

What to do in the first hour, how to report the claim, working with the adjuster and the repair shop, and where to turn if the offer seems wrong.

By Brookguard Editorial Team Updated 7 min read

Report to insurer
As soon as you can
Florida PIP
Treatment within 14 days
Disputes
Appraisal or state insurance dept.
Repair shop
Often your choice
Driver photographing damage to a car's rear door on the shoulder of a city street

The short version

After a crash, get to safety, call the police if anyone is hurt or the cars can't move, and document everything before you leave. Notify your insurer quickly, even if the other driver was at fault, and keep a written record of every conversation. If you disagree with the settlement, you don't have to accept it: your policy and your state insurance department give you options.

At the scene

  1. 1 Check for injuries and call 911 if anyone is hurt.
  2. 2 If the car can be driven and it's safe, move it out of traffic and turn on your hazard lights.
  3. 3 Call the police. For a hit-and-run or a stolen car, report it promptly; insurers usually ask for the report number.
  4. 4 Exchange names, addresses, phone numbers and insurance details with the other driver. If they won't share, note their license plate and driver's license number.
  5. 5 Get names and phone numbers of witnesses before they leave.
  6. 6 Write down the officer's name and badge number and ask how to get the crash report.

Build your evidence file

The record you create in the first day carries the claim. Store everything in one folder on your phone or in a paper envelope.

  • Photos of both cars from several angles, the license plates, the wider scene, traffic signs and skid marks.
  • The time, date and exact location, plus weather and road conditions.
  • A quick sketch of where each car was and which way it was moving.
  • Receipts for towing, a rental, medical visits and anything else you pay for.
  • A log of every call with an insurer: date, name of the person and what was said.

If you were hurt, see a doctor soon, even for soreness that seems minor. Medical records made close to the crash link the injury to it, and a gap of weeks before treatment gives an insurer a reason to question whether the crash caused it.

Whose insurer to call

Call your own insurer first, using the number on your insurance card or its app, even if you think the other driver was at fault. Your policy requires prompt notice. Then decide where the damage claim goes.

Your options after a crash
You caused it Your collision fixes your car; your liability pays the other side
The other driver caused it Claim with their insurer (no deductible), or use your own collision and let your insurer recover the cost
The other driver has no insurance or fled Your uninsured motorist or collision coverage
Theft, hail, flood, fire or an animal Your comprehensive coverage
Injuries in a no-fault state Your own personal injury protection first, whoever caused it

Injury claims in no-fault states have strict clocks. In Florida, you must get initial treatment within 14 days of the crash to use PIP medical benefits. In New York, the no-fault application generally must reach the insurer within 30 days if your first notice wasn't in writing. See personal injury protection for how those claims work.

Working with the adjuster

The insurer assigns an adjuster, who may be a staff employee or an independent contractor. The adjuster reviews the facts, inspects the damage in person or from photos and decides what the policy pays.

Do

Answer questions honestly, send documents promptly, keep notes of every call and ask for decisions and explanations in writing.

Don't

Feel pressured to agree on the spot, sign a release before you know the full extent of your injuries, or guess when you aren't sure of a detail.

If the other driver's insurer asks for a recorded statement, you can ask to give the information in writing instead, or check with your own insurer first.

Repairs, rentals and total losses

  • Repair shop: your insurer may suggest a shop, but in many states you can choose your own. Texas, for example, gives drivers the right to choose the shop and parts.
  • Hidden damage: if the shop finds more damage once it takes the car apart, it sends a supplement to the adjuster for approval.
  • Rental: paid by the at-fault driver's insurer, or by your own policy only if you carry rental reimbursement.
  • Total loss: if repairs cost too much compared with the car's value, the insurer pays its actual cash value minus your deductible. Gap coverage handles any loan balance above that.

If you disagree with the outcome

You don't have to accept a payment you think is unfair. Work through these steps in order.

  1. 1 Ask the adjuster to explain the decision in writing and send any evidence that supports your view.
  2. 2 Ask for a supervisor or a second review.
  3. 3 If the disagreement is about the dollar value, check your policy for an appraisal clause, which lets each side hire an appraiser and use an umpire to settle the amount.
  4. 4 Contact your state insurance department's consumer services unit; it can look into how the claim was handled.
  5. 5 For large or complex claims, consider a lawyer or, where your state allows it, a licensed public adjuster.

Each state also sets a deadline for filing a lawsuit over a crash, called a statute of limitations, and it can be only a few years. Don't let a slow claim run past it. Claims can affect your premium at renewal, especially at-fault ones; the deductibles guide explains when paying a small repair yourself makes sense.

Common questions

Should I report a small accident if no one was hurt?

Tell your insurer about any crash involving another driver, even a minor one. If the other person later claims an injury or damage and you didn't report it, your insurer may have grounds to deny coverage.

How long does a car insurance claim take?

Simple repair claims often settle within a few weeks. Claims with injuries, disputed fault or a total loss take longer. Many states set rules on how quickly insurers must acknowledge and answer claims.

Can my insurer make me use its preferred shop?

In many states, no. The insurer can recommend a shop and may offer perks like a repair warranty, but you can usually choose where the car is fixed.

Sources

Facts on this page were checked against these sources on October 12, 2026. Claim deadlines and repair-shop rules differ by state, so read your policy and your state's consumer guide early.