Skip to content
Brookguard

Should I drop full coverage?

Collision and comprehensive can only pay what your car is worth, minus the deductible. On an older car that ceiling can sink below a few years of premiums.

A private-party value from a pricing guide is a fair figure.

On your declarations page. Not sure? Estimate it from your state's average.

Do you still owe money on the car?
Could you replace the car from savings if it were totaled?

The rule of thumb behind it

A common test is to compare the yearly cost of collision and comprehensive with what the car is worth: once the premium approaches about a tenth of the payout you could get, dropping the coverage starts to make sense — unless a lender requires it or you could not afford another car. The calculator applies thresholds of 7% and 10%; the details are on the methodology page.

Dropping full coverage leaves liability in place, so you stay legal. Read collision and comprehensive before you decide.