Collision Coverage: Paying to Fix Your Own Car
The crashes it covers, how the deductible and your car's value shape every check, and a simple test for deciding whether an older car still needs it.
By Brookguard Editorial Team Updated 6 min read
- Pays for
- Your own car
- Fault
- Pays either way
- Required by
- Lenders, not states
- Payout cap
- Car's actual cash value
The short version
Collision coverage pays to repair or replace your own car after it hits another vehicle or an object, or rolls over, whether or not you caused the crash. You pay the deductible and the insurer pays the rest, up to what the car was worth just before the crash. No state requires it, but almost every auto loan or lease does.
The crashes collision handles
Think of collision as the coverage for impacts while the car is moving. It applies when you hit something or something you're driving into hits back.
- Hitting another vehicle, including a rear-end crash in traffic.
- Striking a fixed object: a tree, guardrail, utility pole, wall or garage door.
- A rollover, such as sliding off an icy road into a ditch.
- Pothole damage to wheels, tires and suspension.
- Damage from a crash where the other driver fled or can't be found.
Collision doesn't pay for mechanical breakdowns, worn parts or damage that builds up over time. Theft, hail, flooding, fire and hitting an animal belong to comprehensive coverage, which is usually bought alongside it.
How a collision payment is calculated
Two numbers decide the check: your deductible and your car's actual cash value, meaning what it was worth just before the crash after age, mileage and condition. Deductibles are often set somewhere between $250 and $1,000, though some insurers offer higher options. A higher deductible lowers the premium.
| Repairable damage, $4,200 estimate | Insurer pays $3,700; you pay $500 |
|---|---|
| Total loss, car worth $11,000 | Insurer pays $10,500; it usually takes the wreck |
| Minor scrape, $450 estimate | No payment, because the damage is under the deductible |
A car is declared a total loss when repairs would cost too much compared with its value. Some states set a fixed percentage of value that triggers it; others let insurers compare repair costs plus salvage value with what the car was worth. If you still owe more on a loan than the payout, gap insurance covers that difference; collision alone does not.
If you think a total-loss offer is too low, ask the adjuster for the valuation report and check it against local listings for the same model, trim and mileage. Many policies include an appraisal clause for value disputes, and your state insurance department can help if you and the insurer still disagree.
If the other driver caused it
You have two routes when someone else is clearly to blame, and each has trade-offs. In either case, report the crash to your own insurer too, even if you don't plan to use your coverage.
Claim with the other driver's insurer
Their property damage liability pays your repairs with no deductible. The catch is time: their insurer may wait to accept fault before approving anything.
Claim on your own collision coverage
Repairs usually start sooner. You pay your deductible first, and your insurer then tries to recover the money from the at-fault driver. If it succeeds, you get your deductible back, sometimes only in part if fault is shared.
In some states, uninsured motorist property damage coverage can step in when the at-fault driver has no insurance, often with a lower deductible than collision. See uninsured motorist coverage for how that works.
Who makes you carry it
No state law requires collision. If you finance or lease, though, your contract almost certainly does, and the lender may also cap your deductible. Let the coverage lapse and the lender can buy a policy for you and add the cost to your loan. That force-placed coverage is typically expensive and protects the lender's interest rather than yours.
Once the car is paid off, collision becomes your call. The right answer depends on what the car is worth and how easily you could pay for a repair or a replacement yourself. A two-year-old car worth $28,000 is a very different risk from a fifteen-year-old commuter worth $3,000, even if both are driven the same way every day.
A quick test for older cars
A common rule of thumb from the insurance industry: if your car is worth less than about ten times what you pay each year for collision and comprehensive, the coverage may no longer be worth the price.
- 1 Look up your car's private-party value using its mileage and condition.
- 2 Find the yearly cost of collision and comprehensive on your declarations page or ask your insurer.
- 3 Subtract your deductible from the car's value. That's the most you could ever collect.
- 4 Ask yourself whether you could replace the car from savings tomorrow without hardship. If not, keeping the coverage may still make sense.
Small choices that change the price
- Raising the deductible from $500 to $1,000 trims the collision premium; the deductibles guide shows how to weigh it.
- Repair costs drive price: cars with expensive sensors and lights cost more to cover.
- Rental reimbursement is a separate add-on; collision itself doesn't pay for a loaner.
- Your driving record matters more for collision than for most other coverages.
One more cost to keep in mind: an at-fault collision claim can raise your premium at renewal, so small repairs close to your deductible are often cheaper to pay yourself.
Common questions
Will collision fix my car if I caused the crash?
Yes. That's the main reason to carry it. Liability pays the other driver, and collision pays for your car minus your deductible.
Do I need collision on a car I own outright?
Not by law. Keep it if you couldn't comfortably repair or replace the car yourself, and consider dropping it once the yearly cost is large compared with the car's value.
Does collision cover a rental car I'm driving?
Many personal policies extend collision to a rental car you drive for personal use, subject to the same deductible. Check your policy wording before declining the rental counter's coverage.
Sources
- Insurance Information Institute — What is covered by a basic auto insurance policy?
- Insurance Information Institute — Nine ways to lower your auto insurance costs
- NAIC — A Consumer's Guide to Auto Insurance
Facts on this page were checked against these sources on October 12, 2026. Dollar figures are examples, not quotes; your policy's wording decides what is covered.
Keep reading
-
Coverage
Comprehensive insurance
Pays for theft, hail, flood, fire, animal strikes and glass damage to your car, minus the deductible.
-
Guide
Deductibles explained
How deductibles work per claim, what a higher one saves, and a break-even test for choosing yours.
-
Coverage
Liability insurance
Pays others for injuries and damage you cause. Required in 49 states and D.C.; minimums vary by state.