Skip to content
Brookguard

Choosing Car Insurance Coverage, One Decision at a Time

A practical order for building a policy: start with the law, protect your savings, decide what your car needs, then fine-tune deductibles and add-ons.

By Brookguard Editorial Team Updated 7 min read

First step
Your state's minimums
Common liability floor
100/300/100
Older-car test
Value under 10x premium
Review
Every renewal
Person at a kitchen table comparing a printed car insurance declarations page with a laptop

The short version

Build your policy in layers. Start with what your state requires, then raise liability limits to match what you could lose in a lawsuit. Add collision and comprehensive if you couldn't easily replace your car, cover your own injuries with PIP, MedPay or UM, and only then choose deductibles and extras.

Start with what your state requires

Every policy has to meet your state's rules first. Those rules set the floor, and they differ more than most people expect.

  • Liability minimums vary widely, from Florida, which requires no bodily injury liability for most drivers, to 50/100/50 in North Carolina since mid-2025.
  • No-fault states, such as Florida, Michigan and New York, require personal injury protection.
  • About 20 states and D.C. require uninsured motorist coverage, and many others include it unless you reject it in writing.
  • New Hampshire doesn't require liability insurance at all, but drivers must be able to pay for damage they cause.

Find your state in our state guide and write down the required coverages and limits. That's your starting line, not your finish line. Minimums were designed to make sure crash victims get something, not to protect the driver who causes the crash, so treat them as a legal checkbox rather than a recommendation.

Protect your savings with liability limits

Liability insurance pays people you injure and property you damage. If a claim is bigger than your limits, the excess can come after your savings, home equity and future wages. That makes liability the most important decision on the policy for anyone with something to lose.

Common liability tiers and who they tend to suit
State minimum Drivers with very few assets who need the lowest legal price
50/100/50 Renters with modest savings
100/300/100 A widely suggested floor for most households
250/500/100 or higher Homeowners and people with significant savings
Umbrella on top Higher net worth; often $1 million or more above your auto and home policies

To pick a tier, add up what a court could reach: savings outside retirement accounts, home equity, a second property, and your future income. Your liability limits should come close to that total. If they can't, because your assets are larger than any auto policy sells, that's the point where an umbrella policy earns its cost. Umbrella insurers usually require fairly high auto limits underneath before they'll write one.

Decide whether your car needs physical damage coverage

Collision repairs your car after a crash, and comprehensive covers theft, weather, fire, glass and animal strikes. Together they're what most people call "full coverage."

You have a loan or lease

The lender almost certainly requires both, and may cap your deductible. Consider gap insurance if you owe more than the car is worth.

The car is paid off and newer

Keeping both usually makes sense unless you could replace the car from savings without strain.

The car is paid off and older

If the car is worth less than about ten times the annual cost of the two coverages, dropping one or both may be reasonable.

High-risk area

Where hail, flooding, wildfire or theft are common, comprehensive is often worth keeping even on an older car because it's relatively cheap.

Cover your own injuries

Liability pays other people. For your own medical bills and lost pay, you have three tools, and the right mix depends on your state and your health plan.

  • PIP pays medical bills, part of lost income and related costs regardless of fault. It's required in no-fault states and some others.
  • MedPay pays medical and funeral costs regardless of fault, without lost-income benefits. It's often a low-cost option in at-fault states.
  • Uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage pays when the driver who hurts you can't. Matching it to your liability limits is the usual advice.

Health insurance may cover treatment, but it doesn't replace wages or pay for pain and suffering, and deductibles can be high. That's why UM/UIM matters even for people with excellent health coverage.

In a no-fault state, PIP is mandatory and pays first. In an at-fault state, ask whether your insurer offers PIP or MedPay and price a small amount; the cost is often low compared with a single emergency room visit.

Set deductibles you can actually pay

A higher deductible lowers your premium for collision and comprehensive. Industry figures suggest raising a deductible from $200 to $500 can cut the cost of those coverages by 15% to 30%, and going to $1,000 can save 40% or more. The trade-off is the bill you face after a claim.

A good rule: choose the highest deductible you could pay next week without borrowing. The deductibles guide has a break-even method.

Add extras that match how you drive

  • Rental reimbursement if you couldn't get by without a car during repairs.
  • Roadside assistance, unless you already have it through a membership or your car maker.
  • A rideshare or delivery endorsement if you drive for an app; personal policies often exclude that use.
  • Custom equipment coverage if you've added aftermarket parts.
  1. 1 Pull your declarations page and list every coverage, limit and deductible.
  2. 2 Mark anything below your state's requirements or your own targets above.
  3. 3 Request quotes with your new targets from at least three insurers using identical limits.
  4. 4 Repeat the review at each renewal and after a move, a new car, a new driver or a big change in savings.

When you're ready to shop, the quote comparison guide shows how to keep the comparison fair.

Common questions

What does "full coverage" actually mean?

It isn't a legal term. Most people use it for liability plus collision and comprehensive, but it doesn't automatically include UM/UIM, rental reimbursement or gap coverage, so check each line.

Is a state minimum policy ever enough?

It's legal, and for someone with almost no assets it may be a reasonable short-term choice. For most people, a serious crash would exceed minimum limits and leave them personally responsible.

How often should I revisit my coverage?

At least once a year at renewal, and any time your life changes: a move, a new car, a teen driver, paying off a loan or buying a home.

Sources

Facts on this page were checked against these sources on October 12, 2026. Prices in the examples are illustrations; your quotes depend on your state, car and driving record.